Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post new topic   Reply to topic

Page 2 of 2 Previous  1, 2

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by Ozrosarian on 23rd June 2010, 5:46 pm

Simon wrote:I'll leave the development of English style roses to others... I love the idea of putting Teas with DA roses to make Aussie Austins but not to make more of the same stuff we already have.


I think that fully double roses from Europe have a mishap here, including Austins. They're okay, seldom great for this climate. Tassy and a colder part of Victoria are the only places in Australia where they can thrive. For this land, singles and semidoubles, noisettes, airy tea hybrids, hybrid musk and gigantea hybrids are, imho, the best.
Therefore Alister Clark was right from the beginning. Pity that we don't see many of the semidoubles and single roses DA has created during the last two decades. There are *plenty* of them, and NONE is available here .. ah, those pig-headed commercial importers and trial nurseries, that form our public taste and limit our choices >8@. They only import what they *think* it's gonna sell. And you end up in a vicious circle of limited choices that form more limited tastes.
So it's their fault, and people are thus used to imagine DA roses as huge doubles with full rosette shape, etc. But that's not true. I did find his Herbalist somewhere (God know when and how that one was imported, because to my knowledge it's available at only one nursery), and ancients like Dapple Dawn & Red Coat, if you're lucky to find them. And that's about it.
But look below at his Cariad, introduced this year! He has introduced 5 roses in 2010, and 2 are semidoubles. And there's no way in hell we can have them.


Ozrosarian
New kid on the block

Number of posts: 40
Location: Melbourne
Registration date: 2010-05-31

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by Rose Petal on 23rd June 2010, 7:26 pm

Red Intuition is a great rose, bush well have not made my mind up as yet, but for long lasting on the bush great and for cut flowers love them, I made this for a friends funeral a few months ago and yes all from the one bush Shocked




Rose Petal
Addict in the making

Number of posts: 114
Location: Victoria
Registration date: 2010-06-03

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by Simon on 23rd June 2010, 8:20 pm

I think it's also an evolution of ideas... semi doubles and singles are, to me, far more valuable in the landscape and allow the plant to invest more heavily in the production of flowers resulting in a greatrer overall impact. As more and more people swing away from roses (unfortunately this has to happen before any forward progress can be made IMO), more suitable roses can be produced. As far as the mass producers dictating the terms of rose fashion... that's why we need to support the smaller specialist rose nurseries and we need to support the recording and exchange of material among enthusiasts as we do here (this is the philosophy behind the rose traders database we have here). Even in Tassie some of the European style roses don't get enough chill hours to flower at their best. This is why I imported Rosa clinophylla seeds. It's a tropical rose known as the swamp rose. Paul Barden has already managed to get nice hybrids using clinopylla and combined with species such as wichurana, gigantea, bracteata, banksiae, roxburghii, and chinensis I think we can reinvent roses here in Australia, as Alister Clark began doing not so long ago. Species such as multiflora will also play a part but in a different way to the way it was traditionally used and species such as persica and rubiginosa will also have a bigger part to play. Rugosa are beautiful but I question how smart it is to use them for roses on mainland Australia... I'll keep using them for roses grown in Tassie as they are hard to beat down here. For me, the criteria is simple... a rose needs to grow well on its own roots (this almost always translates into easy propagation by cuttings... grafting should not be required and is an antiquated form of commercial propagation for all but specialist rose forms such as standards), grow without fuss and extensive soil preparation (despite conventional thinking being that this is good for the soil... it actually isn't. Mulching and other natural processes and products should be the only things added to soil IMO. The less the soil is disturbed the better it is), be able to grow without chemical intervention, have a long hassle-free life, and be useful in the landscape (ie shrubs of various dimensions... no more bare legs). Things like flower form, perfume, evergreen ability, full remontancy, etc are secondary to these other features. The trick is to breed what works in your area and to break the mould of conventional thinking that essentially results in breeders stirring the same old pot of genes that they've been stirring for the last few hundred years. It matters not to me that it might take more than my lifetime... I can always pass the baton on to someone else... so these are my underlying rose principles... a back-to-nature approach from this pantheist Smile

_________________
Favourite quotes:
* All His geese are swans.
* Well-timed silence hath more eloquence than speech.
* Just because you're paranoid, doesn't mean they're not out to get you.

Simon
Admin

Number of posts: 2154
Age: 39
Location: Kindred, Tasmania
Registration date: 2008-02-08

View user profile http://www.rosetalkaustralia.com

Back to top Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by Rose Petal on 23rd June 2010, 8:30 pm

a rose needs to grow well on its own roots (this almost always translates into easy propagation by cuttings... grafting should not be required


100% here Simon, I would never be interested in what you all do , grafting ect... growing from seed until I was fully retired as it would need so much of my time to give my 100% to any project, I love my other plants that I can just break a bit off and way you go and usually better than the parent host as well ! cheers

Rose Petal
Addict in the making

Number of posts: 114
Location: Victoria
Registration date: 2010-06-03

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by Ozeboy on 23rd June 2010, 10:26 pm

I'm trying to breed away from them not to them. Golden Celebration couldn't handle the Aussie heat and humidity and just died. Of the 20 odd DA's I had here all except 2 have either died or were given awayas totally unsuitable for this climate. As I have mentioned before I will leave the banana growing to the Queenslanders and all those English roses to the Poms. The European roses to them for they are breeding the opposite to us. They want snow hardy and we want heat and humidity loving roses.

David Austin is to be admired for he has bred some of the most fantastic roses for his country men and Europe. I am still looking for one of his that will grow well here but unfortunatly can't find one.

Ozeboy
Must seek help...

Number of posts: 443
Location: Glenorie, Sydney NSW
Registration date: 2008-12-28

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by rosemeadow on 24th June 2010, 12:14 am

Great reading your ideas here tonight. Ozrosarian, Cariad is very striking. A shame we won't get it. Petalplace, thats a super rose arrangement you did.

rosemeadow
Rosaholic

Number of posts: 563
Age: 46
Location: Gulgong, N.S.W.
Registration date: 2009-01-10

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Re: Is there a striped class in rose exhibition?

Post by Damo on 28th June 2010, 10:54 pm

I would buy & grow 'Cariad' if I ever got the chance...very nice!!!

I am going to use 4 of David Austin's roses in my crosses this coming season.

Damo
Addict in the making

Number of posts: 291
Age: 35
Location: NSW
Registration date: 2009-12-14

View user profile

Back to top Go down

Page 2 of 2 Previous  1, 2

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


Post new topic   Reply to topic
Permissions of this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum